A lot of people would say the Scout rifle concept, today, is pretty useless. And that even when Copper dreamed it up it was of extraordinary limited utility. Perhaps, but I’ll go you one better. Theres another gun out there:
- It’s too light for big game
- Too heavy for varmints
- Ammo too expensive to plink
- Capacity too little for ‘serious work’
Behold, the gun no one needed but, once discontinued, everyone wanted:
Yup..its a Marlin Camp Carbine in .45 ACP. IYKYK. Right now, several of you are getting ready to tell me about the self-destructing buffers that led to stocks cracking like river ice in the spring. Way ahead of you guys. I also ordered a couple extra 21# recoil springs and several extra poly buffers.
I was minding my own business and stopped in at the gun shop on my lunch hour. This thing caught my eye because, for reasons no one seems to be able to articulate, people hold onto these things with both hands and they seldom seem to turn up on the used market. In fact, I just looked on Gunbroker and found 21 Marlin Camp Carbines and all are 9mm.
I purchased this one and it jammed when I tried to feed a round of FMJ ball into the chamber. No biggie, I know exactly what the story is. Previous owner must have disassembled it and failed to reassemble it properly. Its a ‘known bug’ that you can reassemble this thing in such a manner that the feed ramp is in the wrong position. So, I disassembled, consulted YouTube, reassembled, and things worked fine.
Im not a huge .45 ACP fan. I prefer a higher capacity magazine and I’ll take 17 rounds in a gun that fits my hand just fine versus half that many in a 1911. And while there are double stack mags out there for .45 ACP, most of them result in pistol grip sizes that are rather unwieldy for me. I will say, though, that the S&W M&P .45 do an excellent job of keeping the grip size small while accommodating a double-stack mag.
I own a lot of guns but I have exactly one .45 AARP pistol….a Springfield 1911 I bought many, many years ago. I seldom carry it because anything worth shooting is worth shooting more than once, and a 17-rd 9mm makes me feel safer than a 7-shot 1911. However, it’s a fun gun at the range and sometimes I carry it in the woods. So I figured as long as I’m going to have a 1911 laying around I may as well have a matching carbine. So…I picked up this particular one.
Now, I should mention, I have a Ruger LC Carbine in .45 ACP and it’s not a great gun. It recoils heavily, is ergonomically awkward, and just looks stupid. It’s only claim to fame is the use of double-stack Glock .45 magazines, and the threaded barrel.
The Marlin, on the other hand, has a little bit of class, style, warmth, and charm. It’s a nice little throwback to the 1990’s. It’s a gun that doesn’t really, to me, seems to have a defined role in…anything. But somehow it has a charm to it that just makes it desirable. And we Americans have always enjoyed having a rifle/carbine combo that shared ammo. Having it share magazines as well just sweetens the deal.
Anyway, I picked this up today. Not sure if I’ll keep it in the long-term or not, but it’ll be fun to take to the range and shoot…especially beside the Ruger LC carbine. And, technically, Ruger could reintroduce these since they own Marlin. However, Ruger would be cannibalizing the sales of it’s own carbines, so its pretty solid that this will not happen.



