I saw this article, and thought “Cool. Canned water from preparedness companies is overpriced, maybe this stuff will be cheaper for stockpiling”. Then, I thought about it a while and realized that, IMHO, the evil plastic bottle is, in my experience, a better choice for water that needs to be stashed away in cars, backpacks, etc.
I drink way too much Coca Cola and my preferred delivery vehicle for the pancreas-killing sugar-slurry is the classic 12 oz. aluminum can. And, over the years, I have had those cans explode when frozen, explode when overheated in a car, develop pinhole leaks if dropped or handled roughly, and just generally be a bit less resilient than you would expect from a metal can.
On the other hand, I cannot recall ever accidentally puncturing a plastic water bottle, having one explode from being frozen, or otherwise fail from rough handling. To my way of thinking, the plastic bottle (especially those lovely small hand grenade sized ones) are ideal for the survivalist who wants something they can throw in a bag and not worry about. Heck, remember the news footage from Katrina and Iraq where relief workers would throw plastic bottles of water from trucks into thirsty crowds? I don’t thik you could get away with that with aluminum cans.
The drawback, of course, is that the plastic bottles are transparent and I suppose that, in theory, you could get something start growing in a bottle. But, most water is treated and, assuming the bottle was clean to begin with, it shouldn’t be an issue. Where those plastic bottle really shine is in the winter. I have bottles of water in my vehicle that have gone through a dozen freeze/thaw cycles and they hold up just fine. But, it’s easy enough to test that out for yourself….grab a bottle of water and heave it into the freezer. Once frozen, take it out to thaw. Repeat process several times and I’d be surprised if you have any failures.
The gist of the article is that the aluminum cans are far more recyclable than the plastic bottles. That may be true, but for my purposes it makes no difference. Something that my be called upon to keep me safe and healthy has one guiding rubric – does it work. Little niggling things like ‘is it environmentally friendly’ are way, way, way at the bottom of the list.
So, I suppose I might pick up a six-pack of this canned water if I come across it just to test it against the plastic bottles, but I think that I am far better served with the plastic.


